<h2><strong>1. Understanding Sections 77 (CGST Act) & 19 (IGST Act)</strong></h2><p>? <strong>Section 77 of CGST Act</strong> → If a registered person <strong>wrongly paid CGST+SGST</strong> on a supply <strong>later held to be inter-State (IGST taxable)</strong>, they can <strong>claim a refund of CGST+SGST</strong> after paying IGST.</p><p>? <strong>Section 19 of IGST Act</strong> → If a registered person <strong>wrongly paid IGST</strong> on a supply <strong>later held to be intra-State (CGST+SGST taxable)</strong>, they can <strong>claim a refund of IGST</strong> after paying CGST+SGST.</p><p>? <strong>No Interest Liability</strong> → If a taxpayer corrects the tax head <strong>before any scrutiny, assessment, audit, or adjudication</strong>, <strong>no interest is payable on the correct tax head.</strong></p><hr><h2><strong>2. Meaning of "Subsequently Held"</strong></h2><p>? <strong>"Subsequently held" covers both cases:</strong></p><ul><li><strong>Self-identification by taxpayer</strong> (i.e., taxpayer realizes the mistake and corrects it).</li><li><strong>Determination by tax officers</strong> (via scrutiny, audit, or adjudication).</li></ul><p>? <strong>Refunds are applicable in both cases, provided tax is correctly paid under the right head.</strong></p><hr><h2><strong>3. Time Limit for Filing Refund Claims</strong></h2><p>? <strong>Rule 89(1A) of CGST Rules</strong> (introduced via <strong>Notification No. 35/2021 - Central Tax, dated 24.09.2021</strong>) specifies the <strong>time limit</strong> for refund claims:</p><p>✅ <strong>If tax is paid under the correct head after 24.09.2021:</strong></p><ul><li>Refund application <strong>must be filed within 2 years</strong> from the date of payment under the correct tax head.</li></ul><p>✅ <strong>If tax was paid under the correct head before 24.09.2021:</strong></p><ul><li>Refund application <strong>must be filed within 2 years from 24.09.2021 (i.e., before 23.09.2023).</strong></li></ul><hr><h2><strong>4. Practical Examples of Refund Claim Deadlines</strong></h2><figure class="table"><table><thead><tr><th><strong>Scenario</strong></th><th><strong>Date of Correct Tax Payment</strong></th><th><strong>Last Date for Refund Application</strong></th></tr></thead><tbody><tr><td><strong>Taxpayer realizes mistake & pays IGST</strong></td><td><strong>10.05.2021</strong> (before notification)</td><td><strong>23.09.2023</strong> (2 years from 24.09.2021)</td></tr><tr><td><strong>Taxpayer realizes mistake & pays IGST</strong></td><td><strong>10.11.2021</strong> (after notification)</td><td><strong>09.11.2023</strong> (2 years from tax payment)</td></tr><tr><td><strong>Tax officer determines mistake & IGST is paid</strong></td><td><strong>10.05.2019</strong> (before notification)</td><td><strong>23.09.2023</strong> (2 years from 24.09.2021)</td></tr><tr><td><strong>Tax officer determines mistake & IGST is paid</strong></td><td><strong>10.11.2022</strong> (after notification)</td><td><strong>09.11.2024</strong> (2 years from tax payment)</td></tr></tbody></table></figure><p>? <strong>Same rule applies when IGST is wrongly paid instead of CGST+SGST.</strong></p><hr><h2><strong>5. Refund Not Allowed If Credit Note Is Issued</strong></h2><p>? <strong>Refund under Section 77 / Section 19 is NOT allowed if:</strong></p><ul><li>The taxpayer <strong>issued a credit note under Section 34 of CGST Act</strong> to adjust the tax amount.</li></ul><p>? <strong>Reason:</strong> If tax is <strong>adjusted through credit note</strong>, it is assumed that the taxpayer has already settled the tax adjustment.</p><hr><h2><strong>6. Trade Notices & Implementation</strong></h2><p>? <strong>CBIC directs tax authorities</strong> to issue trade notices ensuring businesses understand these clarifications.<br>? Any <strong>challenges in implementation</strong> should be reported to CBIC.<a href="https://cms.plasament.com/storage/shubham-pathak/circular-no-162-18-2021-gst.pdf">Circular-No-162-18-2021-GST</a><br> </p>